Rob Reviews…Dune, part 2

Published by

on

A few weeks ago, I wrote about hearing how great Dune, part 2 is. One would think that over the course of my life I would learn my lesson and stop believing the hype.

It’s not that Dune, Part 2 was so bad. I think sometimes however when I hear a lot of hype about something, I set my expectations so high that I am inevitably let down by it.

Of course, maybe this just could have been the inevitable let down of the second act of any trilogy. When people were calling this movie “ Empire Strikes Back levels of greatness” I’m expecting something pretty mind blowing.

I think sometimes it might just be that while I love world building stories, I love the first act of said stories, where I’m introduced to a new world and there’s a certain level of fascination learning all about it. Obviously, with any sequel, you don’t have to tell any back story or origin story and you can really get into the heart of the story you’re trying to tell. That seems to be the case with Dune part 2.

Timothée Chalamet returns as Paul lAtreides in Dune, part 2.

Dune is not a heroic story, at all. Even though I’ve never read frank herbert’s original novel, I know enough about the story to understand this going into the movie. In fact, dune is more the story about what happens when one ascends to a position of absolute rule.

That’s all well and good l. I knew all this going into the movie. What was odd to me is the fact that even though Part 2 is 2 1/2 hours in running time, it’s never really clear at what point Paul decides to follow the prophecies. For the first third of the movie he is dead set against taking certain actions that would coincide with the prophecies he has seen. Then suddenly he’s like “OK. I’ll just go with the flow”.  Amazingly enough Dune part 2 manages to be both drawn out and a little bit rash. This is especially striking considering that this is the second part of a story and the film begins literally where part one left off. There is no “previously on Dune” segment at as the movie begins 

Dune, Part 2 leaves a bad taste in my mouth. That’s exactly how it was supposed to be. And even though source material is nearly 60 years old itself, it’s a message about succumbing to tyranny as timeless. However I can’t feel like it’s coincidental that the movie came out in the middle of the trump presidency. Part 2, being released just months before the 2024 elections seems like a last ditch warning cry to the public About the dangers of absolute rule.

FINAL TAKE: Recommended, if, for no other reason than to see the conclusion of part one. Dune is epic. It is world building. It is an adventure, but Paul Atreides is no Luke Skywalker. As long as you know that going into the movie, you’ll be satisfied.

Thanks for stopping by Rebuilding Rob. Be sure to like, comment and subscribe to my blog below. It’s greatly appreciated! Also, feel free to follow me on social media as well! Check out my most recent posts as well as some earlier, related posts:

The article “Rob reviews… Dune, part 2“ first appeared on Rebuilding Rob

11 responses to “Rob Reviews…Dune, part 2”

  1. MaryG Avatar

    Agree, I didn’t love it either (and I didn’t see Dune 1 or read the books) my favorite parts were those dragonfly ornithopters and the sand worms – basically the special effects. My husband liked it better. I think he liked Brolin.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. rebuilding rob Avatar

      This is a tough movie to jump into if you haven’t seen the first one. I think you’d like it more if you saw part one. But if you’re like me, I think you’ll end up liking part one more.

      Brolin totally uses his Thanos voice in this movie!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. MaryG Avatar

        Did you see him on SNL? He really has a giant head, in proportion to his body. Perfect for movies.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. rebuilding rob Avatar

        🤣

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Silk Cords Avatar

    Dune is definitely a different beast than Star Wars. The theme is darker as you pointed out; the message more traditional old school sci-fi in it’s warnings. It sounds like there definitely should have been an “aha” moment for Paul, even if it’s something as subtle as him going wide eyed and grinning as a crowd cheers him on. Instant heel turns can work that way. I never read the book, so I can’t say if that’s a failing on Frank Herbert’s part or the movie conversion writers. Given Herbert’s reputation as an author, I’d lean towards the movie adaptation writers.

    The political messages… Well, they kind of ruined the Star Wars prequels for me also, BUT they’re all valid and applicable to both parties. I used to think Ross Perot was out there stating how he was blackmailed with the safety of his family and forced to withdraw his candidacy. Seeing the trail of “suicides” the Clintons left in their wake and what Trump is willing to push his people to do, I’m not so sceptical anymore.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. rebuilding rob Avatar

      I did run to the bathroom a few times during the movie, so it’s possible i might have missed the “a ha” moment for Paul.

      That’s an interesting take on Perot. I was of the mind that he really did NOT want to be president so he dropped out of the race – and dropped back in because he was caving to pressure by his supporters. I always got the impression that he was reluctant spokesman.

      Either way, the in and out thing he pulled was enough to kill any momentum he had in that campaign.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Silk Cords Avatar

        My dad was a rabid Perot supporter (career military at the time also), and was very up on the conspiracy and what Perot said about his dropping out. The media did everything they could to paint Perot as a nutjob after he said that. THAT killed his campaign more than anything.

        Note that now everything from both sides is about similar conspiracies by the other. Things that make you go hmmmm….

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Huilahi Avatar
    Huilahi

    Great review. I appreciate your honesty here. I’ve heard nothing but praise surrounding this film which made me think that it was a masterpiece. It’s good to hear a more balanced perspective. I’m still looking forward to seeing it because I was such a massive fan of the first “Dune”. Here’s why I loved the first film so much: https://huilahimovie.reviews/2021/10/28/dune-2021-movie-review/

    Liked by 1 person

    1. rebuilding rob Avatar

      I think the problem I had with part two was the same issue that I have with two part episodes of TV shows: part one sets up the story so well, that it’s very difficult for part two to surpass it.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Huilahi Avatar
        Huilahi

        Fair criticism. I have yet to see the film but I do feel Denis Villeneuve was the perfect filmmaker to take on this movie. He’s always excelled at making sci-fi movies with serious concepts. I loved his work on “Arrival”. Here’s why that movie is worth seeing if you haven’t already seen it:

        "Arrival" (2016)- Movie Review

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Huilahi Avatar
    Huilahi

    Great review once again. I had the opportunity to finally see the movie and it seems as though I enjoyed it far more than you did. A spectacular sequel that found fresh ways to surpass standards set by its predecessor. I loved the authentic depictions of Middle East which was also evident in the first film. Here’s why I adored the sequel:

    “Dune: Part Two” (2024) – Movie Review

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment